105 - Issue Automation - Keeping your issues squeaky clean

Objective:

When you use issues and labels to manage day to day work and define a specific process, often there are situations and times where it’s hard to keep labels in the right status. For example:

Label Hygene: Consider a situation where there is a process defined by an overall label (ABC) and the specific steps in the process are defined by the scoped labels (ABC::1, ABC::2, and ABC::3)
The process assumes that everyone in the team will assign “ABC” and one of the scoped labels “ABC::x”
However it’s likely that people will forget to assign both labels, and over time there will be a mixture of issues missing one of the two labels.
Label Hygiene Consider a process, where you want to summarize issues based on a set of detailed labels that might be assigned to them. Such as, a process where there are 10 scoped labels “ZYX::1, ZYX::2, ZYX::3, … ZYX::10”, and you want to summarize them in to “ODD” and “EVEN”. So ZYX::2,4,6,8,10 all would be labeled “EVEN” and ZYX::1,3,5,7,9 would be labeled “ODD”.
You could request your team to update their issues with the right “ODD”/“EVEN” labels based on the ZYX::nnn label
You could bulk update labels (find all the ZYX::1 issues and then add the “ODD” label, and repeat 9 more times) In either case, the ODD/EVEN summary labels would be most likely incorrect, as people would forget to update them, or if something changed, they would be wrong

There are other key situations where automation can help. (see below for these practical examples)

Moving issues to a certain project - consider a situation where you have an issue or group of issues that you want to periodically move to a specific project.
Promoting issues to be epics - consider a situation where you have a set of related epics you want to re-create. You have the epics defined as issue templates and want them to automatically be promoted to be epics.
Deprecating/deleting an issue - Consider where you have an issue that you want to effectivley delete and therefore remove all the lables, epics, estimates, milestones etc.

Automation can address all of these situations and streamline work.

Solution - Label Hygiene / Triage Bot

Define a set of rules that will automatically

Add a label when it is missing
Change or remove a label when it’s wrong
Add a comment, mention a user, and more thorough comments and /quick actions.

The Triage Bot is an Open GitLab project that makes it possible to automate many issue and merge request hygiene tasks to ensure that your projects are more consistently following a given process.

Example Triage Policies/rules

Here are two examples of how Triage Polices/Rules can automate updates and issue hygiene:

This example finds issues that are more than 5 days old, but have no label associated with them, then it adds a comment to ask the Author to do something. The policy also notifies a team member to make them aware of the issue.

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19


       - name: My policy
        conditions:
          date:
            attribute: updated_at
            condition: older_than
            interval_type: days
            interval: 5
          state: opened
          labels:
            - No Label
        limits:
          most_recent: 50
        actions:
          labels:
            - needs attention
          mention:
            - markglenfletcher
          comment: |
            {{author}} This issue is unlabelled after 5 days. It needs attention. Please take care of this before the end of #{2.days.from_now.strftime('%Y-%m-%d')}            

In Strategic marketing, here is a rule that finds any Strategic marketing Requests that are missing a Scoped Workflow label.

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18


      - name: sm_request (MISSING a scoped label and assign it as a New Reqeust)
        conditions:
          labels:
            - sm_request
          state: opened
          forbidden_labels:
            - sm_req::triage
            - sm_req::transfered
            - sm_req::new_request
            - sm_req::declined
            - sm_req::completed
            - sm_req::backlog
            - sm_req::assigned
        actions:
          labels:
            - sm_req::new_request
          comment: |
           SM TriageBot helping out here: This SM Request issue was not in the workflow, automatically adding it as a new request.           

Setting Up the Triage Bot:

There are only two simple steps to set up the TriageBot.

Configuring your CI/CD pipeline
Drafting your first Triage Policy
Setting up a CI/CD Schedule to run your Triage Policies periodically.

Step 1: Configuring your CI/CD Pipeline for the first time.

The triage bot runs as a scheduled CI pipeline job, so your project will need to define a gitlab-ci.yml file. The gitlab-ci.yml file is stored in the root directory of your project.

Here is an example of the Product and Solution Marketing pipeline, where there are three Jobs defined. There are two Manual jobs, and one Scheduled Job. The two Manual jobs either test(dry-run) the rules/policies, or actually apply the rules/policies (policy:run). The one Scheduled job (schedule:policyrun), when runs will actually apply the rules/policies.

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31


 >image: ruby:2.7
 stages:
  - triage
  - run

dry-run:triage:
  stage: triage
  script:
    - gem install gitlab-triage
    - gitlab-triage --help
    - gitlab-triage --dry-run --token $API_TOKEN --source projects --source-id $CI_PROJECT_PATH
  when: manual
  except:
    - schedules

policy:run:
  stage: run
  script:
    - gem install gitlab-triage
    - gitlab-triage --token $API_TOKEN --source projects --source-id $CI_PROJECT_PATH
  when: manual
  except:
    - schedules

schedule:policyrun:
  stage: run
  script:
    - gem install gitlab-triage
    - gitlab-triage --token $API_TOKEN --source projects --source-id $CI_PROJECT_PATH
  only:
    - schedules

The TriageBot needs to have access and permission to your GitLab project to read and update issues. This is called a “token”, and is stored in GitLab using a “CI/CD Variable” - in this case it is the $API_TOKEN that you see in the above example pipeline.

You will need to configure a GitLab CI/CD Environment Variable$API_TOKEN for these jobs to run.

Here’s how:

2. Setting Up CI-CD API Token Variable	Image
1. In your project select the left menu option `Settings-->CI/CD`	{: .margin-right20 .margin-left20 .margin-top20 .margin-bottom20 .image-width30pct }
2. Then expand the `Variables` section	{: .margin-right20 .margin-left20 .margin-top20 .margin-bottom20 .image-width80pct }
3. Add a new line where - Type= “Variable” - Key = “API_TOKEN” - Value = Your API Key. - You have an API Key don’t you? (See short instructions below) - Set Masked to True.	{: .margin-right20 .margin-left20 .margin-top20 .margin-bottom20 .image-width80pct }
4. Save Variables

3. Getting your API Key	Image
1. The API Key is linked to your account and basically gives the Bot permission to act on your behalf. First click on the dropdown on your personal settings in GitLab.	{: .margin-right20 .margin-left20 .margin-top20 .margin-bottom20 .image-width50pct }
2. Select `Access Tokens` and - Give the access token a Name - Leave the Expiration Date blank (unless you want it to expire) - Select “API” for the Scopes - Click Create personal access token
3. The Personal Access Token will appear at the top of the page.
4. Copy the Token and then Add it to the API_TOKEN Value in the CI/CD Variables settings.

Step 2: Setting up your FIRST Triage policy

The Triage Policies/Rules are defined in a YML file called .triage-policies.yml which is stored in the root directory of your project. For DETAILED instructions about rules and policy options read the Defining a Policy section in the README.md file in the Triage Bot project.

Create a new file in the root directory called .triage-policies.yml
Paste in the following first simple rule:

1
2
3
4
5
6


  resource_rules:
    issues:
      rules:
        - name: find all open issues - any label (simple - should be lots)
          conditions:
           state: opened

Commit and merge your changes.

This will trigger a pipeline, where the Jobs should all be skipped. You should see this at the bottom of your screen. {: .margin-right20 .margin-left20 .margin-top20 .margin-bottom20 .image-width80pct }

4. Dry-Run TriageBot	Image
1. Click on the Pipeline link and go to the pipeline screen	{: .margin-right20 .margin-left20 .margin-top20 .margin-bottom20 .image-width80pct }
2. Run the “Dry Run” pipeline job.	{: .margin-right20 .margin-left20 .margin-top20 .margin-bottom20 .image-width80pct }
3. Click on the job and watch it run.	{: .margin-right20 .margin-left20 .margin-top20 .margin-bottom20 .image-width80pct }
4. Fist it starts by creating a container and getting a runner growing (That means your CI job is defined OK so far)	{: .margin-right20 .margin-left20 .margin-top20 .margin-bottom20 .image-width80pct }
5. Then it prompts the Triage bot to show it’s help output (that means it’s working, and your API key is good)	{: .margin-right20 .margin-left20 .margin-top20 .margin-bottom20 .image-width80pct }
6. Then the job runs the “Dry-Run” and you see the output from the bot as it runs. Just one job - find all the open issues, so it runs fast, finds over 1,000 issues. Since the policy/rule had no filters or actions, the job finishes.	{: .margin-right20 .margin-left20 .margin-top20 .margin-bottom20 .image-width80pct }

Now, you need to define any specific policies/rules that you need for your project.

Step 3: Scheduling Jobs

Scheduling Jobs	Image
1. Go to CI/CD–>Pipelines on the left menu	{: .margin-right20 .margin-left20 .margin-top20 .margin-bottom20 .image-width20pct }
2. Click on Create New Schedule	{: .margin-right20 .margin-left20 .margin-top20 .margin-bottom20 .image-width80pct }
3. Create the schedule - Write a Name/description - Select an Interval pattern (how frequently do you want it to run. Probably daily.) - Leave the `Target Branch`, and `Variables` options with the default - Click on Save Pipeline Schedule.	{: .margin-right20 .margin-left20 .margin-top20 .margin-bottom20 .image-width80pct }

Other specific scenarios

Moving issues to a certain project

Create a label in your project that is the flag that tells the automation bot to move the issue.

The label must be unique for the destination project. For example move--> project2Test

Update .triage-policies.yml
Paste in the following rule:

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11


  resource_rules:
    issues:
      rules:
        - name: 1. Mooving an issue to another project based on the label - move to Test Project 2
          conditions:
            labels: 
              - move--> project2Test            
            state: opened
          actions:
            comment: |
             /move gitlab-com/marketing/strategic-marketing/testgroup-pmm-isights/testproject2             

This rule will look for the label move--> project2Test in all open issues and then apply the quick action

/move .... where it specifies the destination for the issue.

In the future if you want to move a bunch of issues to that project, all you have to do is add the move--> project2Test label.

Promoting issues to be epics

Create a label in your project that is the flag that tells the automation bot to promote the issue to be an epic.

For example promote-me

Update your .triage-policies.yml
Paste in the following rule:

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11


  resource_rules:
    issues:
      rules:
      - name: 1.2 Promote Issues to epics
        conditions:
          labels: 
            - promote-me            
          state: opened
        actions:
          comment: |
           /promote             

This rule will look for the label promote-me in all open issues and then apply the quick action

/promte which promotes the issue into an epic.

In the future if you want to promote a bunch of issues, all you have to do is add the promote-me label.

Deprecating/deleting an issue

If you want to effectively delete an issue (strip it of labels, remove it from epics and milestones,and remove estimates, and close it)

Create a label in your project that is the flag that tells the automation bot to promote the issue to be an epic.

For example deprecate-me

Update your .triage-policies.yml
Paste in the following rule:

 1
 2
 3
 4
 5
 6
 7
 8
 9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16


  resource_rules:
    issues:
      rules:
      - name: 1.1 - Deprecate Issues Close and strip labels of deprecated issues
        conditions:
          labels: 
            - deprecate-me            
          state: opened
        actions:
          comment: |
           /remove_milestone 
           /remove_epic 
           /remove_estimate 
           /unlabel 
           /title Deprecated Issue
           /close            

This rule will look for the label deprecate-me in all open issues and then apply a bunch of quick actions that update and close the issue.

In the future if you want to delete and deprecate a bunch of issues, all you have to do is add the deprecate-me label.

Success and Next Steps.

From here, you can build/draft your specific policies/rules for your project.

Last modified November 21, 2023: Post marketing migration link migration (95292dbd)

View page source - Edit this page - please contribute.