GitLab is open core, GitHub is closed source

Jul 20, 2016 · 1 min read · Leave a comment
Sid Sijbrandij GitLab profile

Disclosure: I'm the CEO of GitLab and we compete with GitHub.

We think of ourselves as an open source company. But today paxcoder on Hacker News rightly remarked that calling it an open core company is more accurate.

We ship GitLab CE which is open source and GitLab EE that is closed source. We try to be a good steward of the open source project. GitLab EE is proprietary, closed source code but we try to work in a way similar to GitLab CE: the issue tracker is publicly viewable and the EE license allows modifications.

When we mention that GitLab is available in an open source edition people frequently ask "Isn't GitHub open source?". I understand the confusion between open source hosting and open source software. The hosted service is free for open source projects and it has fundamentally improved open source collaboration. But the software GitHub's service is based on is closed source.

At the end of a presentation in Spanish at RubyConf Argentina in 2012 (our English translation) you see someone in the audience ask why GitHub isn't open source. The presenter's answer is that this would hurt their business. Also mentioned in the presentation is that GitHub encrypts their source code with Ruby Encoder and they have text in the license that forbids customers from using GitHub Enterprise to compete with

Of course, GitHub has every right to close and encrypt their source code. GitHub very actively contributes to open source themselves, including many contributions to Git and Ruby on Rails, and releasing libraries and applications like libgit2, Atom, and Hubot. Also note that we build GitLab with software that GitHub open sourced such as libgit2.

In conclusion (TLDR), GitLab has an open core business model and ships both open and closed source software. GitHub hosts most open source projects but ships closed source software.

Try all GitLab features - free for 30 days

GitLab is more than just source code management or CI/CD. It is a full software development lifecycle & DevOps tool in a single application.

Try GitLab Free
Git is a trademark of Software Freedom Conservancy and our use of 'GitLab' is under license

Try the GitLab DevOps Platform for free for 30 days

Achieve higher productivity, faster and secure deployments

Start your free trial Maybe later